My opinion?

[ He's asking, so she should give it though she wonders why he's not bringing up her injury unlike the others. Maybe he doesn't see it? Success! ]

I don't think she should be killed either. In my experience, when someone tells an angry crowd that's been held captive that killing someone who is oblivious to their plight is the way to go about things, it's because that person is bitter. Those ghosts recently... don't you think they were upset too?